Prospect of Growth

Introduction

Economic growth is a central focus of economic theory and policy, as it is closely linked to improvements in living standards, technological advancement, and societal development. Understanding the drivers of growth, the role of productivity and capital formation, the constraints faced, and the critical importance of energy access is essential for formulating effective growth strategies. This analysis will succinctly:

1. Explicate the prospects for economic growth.

2. Detail the drivers of growth, including productivity and capital formation.

3. Discuss constraints to growth drivers and capital formation.

4. Analyse the importance of access to energy as a driver of productivity.

5. Explore means to release constraints to growth.

6. Provide models and proofs, including an extended productivity model accounting for energy.

Prospects for economic growth

Before the industrial era, which has no clear start date but is believed to have gathered a critical amount of momentum around the year 1750, economic growth was slow and largely driven by the agricultural output of villages. Improvements in productivity came from optimizations of tools and land use, or from increasing the workforce. Mercantilism was beginning to grow globally during the age of sail. Changes in financial and business structures, along with scientific advancements started a shift from village-based agrarian lifestyles to industrialized city-based life. Companies like the Dutch and British East India Companies set the foundations of corporations to develop. After 1750 and the utilization of the water mill in the textile industry to greatly increase productivity, economic growth accelerated significantly, spurring on further technological innovation and capital accumulation, becoming what we understand as the First Industrial Revolution. Through each of the subsequent ages of innovation (Age of Steam and Railways (1829); Age of Steel and Heavy Engineering (1875); Age of Oil, Electricity, the Automobile and Mass Production (1908); Age of Information and Telecommunications (1971)) economic growth trends followed an exponential curve. In 275 years humanity progressed from mostly parochial village life through three industrial revolutions to the modern interconnected world on the cusp of a fourth. However developed economies are now facing lowing growth rates due to aging populations and high government debt levels, while emerging economies have the potential for high growth through industrialization and adoption of existing technologies. Climate change, resource constraints, demographics, indebtedness and geopolitical tensions are challenges to be faced if we are to attain sustained growth globally.

Drivers of economic growth

Economic growth is driven by several interrelated factors: Capital accumulation; technological progress; productivity improvements; and access to energy. These factors can be broken down into components. Physical capital is the investments in machinery, infrastructure, and technology that enhance productive capacity. Human capital includes education and skill development that improve labor productivity. Innovation is the development of new products and processes that increases efficiency. General Purpose Technologies (GPTs) are technologies that have broad applications and spur further innovations. Examples include the steam engine, the AC transformer, and the internet. Total Factor Productivity (TFP) is a measure of the efficiency with which inputs are transformed into outputs. Productivity growth is key to long-term economic growth beyond capital accumulation. Energy as an input is essential for production processes and greatly improves the productivity of capital and labor. Energy infrastructure, as an example the AC Grid, a GPS made possible by the transformer (an influential GPT), ensures the reliable energy supply that enables industrial activities and technological applications to value creation through work.

The role of capital formation

The Solow-Swan model emphasizes capital accumulation and technological progress as drivers of growth. It is most commonly expressed as a production function:

$$Y(t) = A(t) \cdot K(t)^\alpha \cdot L(t)^{1-\alpha}$$

Where Y(t) is the output at time t; A(t) is the total factor productivity; K(t) is capital stock; L(t) is labor input; and α is capital’s share of output with a range of (0<α<1). Endogenous growth models incorporate human capital as a driver of sustained growth with education and training used to enhance labor productivity and adaptability. Diminishing returns, resource scarcity and environmental degradation, and limits on the savings rate related to income levels and consumption needs will constrain capital formation. Political instability, poor governance, and economic uncertainty deter investment and limit prospective growth, particularly where excessive regulation hinders business activity and a lack of secure property rights discourage investment.

Importance of access to energy as a driver of productivity

A lack of access to modern energy services limits economic activities and inadequate energy infrastructure hampers productivity. Traditional production functions often overlook energy as a direct input. Incorporating energy provides a more comprehensive model. Studies show a strong relationship between energy consumption and GDP growth.1Improvements in energy efficiency also contribute to productivity gains. An energy-adjusted production function can be expressed as:

$$Y(t) = A(t) \cdot K(t)^\alpha \cdot L(t)^\beta \cdot E(t)^\gamma$$

Where E(t) is energy input andγrepresents the output elasticity of energy. With this model we can see how innovations in energy production like renewable energy can drive growth and how energy-related GPTs like electricity have widespread impacts on production.

Means to release constraints to growth

There are four key areas where the constraints to growth can be reduced: innovation, infrastructure investment, policy reforms and energy transition strategies.Research and development (R&D) investment fosters new technologies. This can also lead to spillover effects where innovations benefit multiple sectors beyond their original targets.Energy infrastructure expansion improves access to reliable energy sources. Technologies that enhance connectivity and efficiency improve productivity across economies, as seen with telephony and the internet.Improving governance quality, reducing corruption, and streamlining regulations can encourage investment and boost capital formation.Renewable energy adoption reduces dependency on finite resources and energy efficiency measures lower the energy intensity of economic activities.

Models and proofs

Extended Solow model including energy

This model can be used to derive the steady-state levels of capital, labor, and energy inputs.

Production function:

$$Y(t) = A(t) \cdot K(t)^\alpha \cdot L(t)^\beta \cdot E(t)^\gamma$$

Assuming constant returns to scale (α + β + γ = 1) and diminishing marginal returns for each input.

Capital accumulation equation:

$$\frac{dK(t)}{dt} = s_Y \cdot Y(t) - \delta_K \cdot K(t)$$ Where s_Y is the savings rate and δ_K is the depreciation rate of capital.

Energy resource dynamics:

If energy comes from exhaustible resources then

$$\frac{dE(t)}{dt} = - \theta \cdot E(t)$$

Where θ represents the rate of energy resource depletion.

Endogenous growth models

AK model:

$$Y(t) = A \cdot K(t)$$

Assuming no diminishing returns and constant returns to scale in capital.

Incorporating human capital and energy:

$$Y(t) = A \cdot K(t)^\alpha \cdot H(t)^\beta \cdot E(t)^\gamma$$

Where H(t) is human capital stock.

Proof of energy’s impact on productivity

Total Factor Productivity (TFP) growth accounting:

The growth rate of output can be decomposed into contributions from inputs and TFP

$$\frac{\dot{Y}}{Y} = \alpha \frac{\dot{K}}{K} + \beta \frac{\dot{L}}{L} + \gamma \frac{\dot{E}}{E} + \frac{\dot{A}}{A}$$

Where Ẏ/Y is the output growth rate and Ȧ/A is the TFP growth rate.

Empirical findings:

Studies incorporating energy find that a significant portion of productivity growth is attributable to energy inputs.2

Conclusion

Economic growth prospects depend on the effective harnessing of drivers such as capital formation, technological progress, and productivity improvements. Capital accumulation, both physical and human, plays a crucial role but faces constraints like diminishing returns and resource limitations. Access to energy emerges as a fundamental driver of productivity, influencing both capital and labor effectiveness. Incorporating energy into growth models provides a more accurate representation of economic dynamics. Releasing constraints to growth involves fostering technological innovation, investing in infrastructure (especially energy infrastructure), implementing policy reforms to improve institutional quality, and transitioning towards sustainable energy sources. General Purpose Technologies, including energy-related innovations, can have transformative impacts on the economy by enabling new processes and industries. Understanding and addressing the constraints and drivers of growth is essential for policymakers aiming to achieve sustainable and inclusive economic development. In the present period, facing the possibility of a fourth Industrial Revolution, challenged by demography, indebtedness and fragile social cohesion, nations like Germany and the United Kingdom with historically high energy costs have cause to consider their policy choices and their long term impact on wellbeing. This analysis integrates key concepts from the cited economic literature to provide a comprehensive understanding of the prospects for economic growth, the drivers and constraints, and the critical role of energy in productivity and growth models. The models and proofs included demonstrate how energy can be incorporated into traditional economic growth frameworks to better capture the material impact of energy on the economy and human welfare.

Bibliography

Berndt, Ernst R., and David O. Wood. Technology, Prices, and the Derived Demand for Energy. The Review of Economics and Statistics (1975), 57(3), 259-268.
Bresnahan, Timothy F., and Manuel Trajtenberg. General Purpose Technologies: ’Engines of Growth’? Journal of Econometrics (1995), 65(1), 83-108.
Cleveland, Cutler J., et al.Energy and the U.S. Economy: A Biophysical Perspective.Science (1984), 225(4665), 890-897.
Gordon, Robert. The Rise and Fall of American Growth. Princeton University Press (2016).
International Energy Agency (IEA). (2017). Energy Access Outlook 2017.
Jorgenson, Dale Weldeau, and Zvi Griliches. The Explanation of Productivity Change. The Review of Economic Studies (1967), 34(3), 249-283.
Lucas Jr, Robert E. On the Mechanics of Economic Development. Journal of Monetary Economics (1988), 22(1), 3-42.
Angus, Maddison. The World Economy: A Millennial Perspective. OECD Publishing (2001).
North, Douglass C. Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance. Cambridge University Press (1990).
Rebelo, Sergio. Long-Run Policy Analysis and Long-Run Growth. Journal of Political Economy (1991), 99(3), 500-521.
Romer, Paul M. Endogenous Technological Change. Journal of Political Economy (1990), 98(5), S71-S102.
Solow, Robert M. A contribution to the theory of economic growth. The quarterly journal of economics 70.1 (1956): 65-94.
Stern, David I. The Role of Energy in Economic Growth. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences (2011), 1219(1), 26-51.
Stern, David I., & Astrid Kander. The Role of Energy in the Industrial Revolution and Modern Economic Growth. The Energy Journal (2012), 33(3), 125-152.

References

[1] Ayres, Robert U., & Warr, Benjamin. The Economic Growth Engine: How Energy and Work Drive Material Prosperity. Edward Elgar Publishing (2009).
[2] Stern, David I. A Multivariate Cointegration Analysis of the Role of Energy in the U.S. Macroeconomy. Energy Economics (2000), 22(2), 267-283.